In short: a traction substation produces two unrelated noises. Transformer hum is tonal, continuous and concentrated at twice the supply frequency, which is 100 Hz on a 50 Hz system, with harmonics above it. Cooling fans and pumps are broadband. A barrier screens the fans; it cannot screen the hum, because at 100 Hz the barrier is acoustically small and the sound simply diffracts over it.
Substations are increasingly the subject of complaint because they run all night and because low frequency tonal noise is more annoying per decibel than broadband traffic noise. A design that treats the whole compound as one source and wraps it in a barrier will usually satisfy the fans and fail on the hum.
Because of the wavelength. At 100 Hz the wavelength is about 3.4 m, and a 3 m to 4 m barrier is comparable to it, so diffraction over the top is efficient and the shadow behind the barrier is shallow.
Tonal and continuous: the ear integrates it over time, so it is more noticeable than an equivalent broadband level.
Harmonics at 200 Hz, 300 Hz and above are easier to attenuate, which is why a barrier can change the character of the noise without much reducing the overall level.
Night-time background is low, so the same source becomes prominent when the site is quiet.
Structure-borne paths through the foundation and the compound wall bypass the air path entirely.
From magnetostriction in the core, which makes the transformer laminations change dimension twice per supply cycle. The result is a tone at 100 Hz on a 50 Hz system, with a harmonic series, and the level depends on the flux density in the core.
This matters for procurement: two transformers of the same rating can differ by several decibels, and the sound level is a purchasable parameter, not a fixed consequence.
| Source | Character | Barrier effect |
|---|---|---|
| Transformer core hum | Tonal, 100 Hz plus harmonics | Small; diffraction over the top dominates |
| Cooling fans and radiators | Broadband, mid to high frequency | Effective if the fan discharge is in line of sight |
| Pumps and compressors | Broadband with tonal components | Effective, or better enclosed |
| Switchgear operation | Intermittent impulsive | Largely unaffected; a local enclosure is better |
At the source or in an enclosure, not at the boundary. The order of preference is: buy a quieter transformer, isolate it, enclose it, and only then screen the site.
Low noise transformer specification with a guaranteed sound level and a measurement standard, since the reduction is designed into the core.
Anti-vibration isolation between the transformer and its foundation, which reduces structure-borne transmission into the compound wall and the ground.
Total enclosure with the cooling circuit moved outside, which is the only reliable way to cut the hum at the source.
Barrier walls inside the compound, close to the transformer, which work better than a boundary barrier because the path length to the top edge is shorter.
Because they run when the transformer is loaded, which is often at night in traction service, and because their noise is broadband and directional, pointing wherever the radiator faces.
Orienting the radiator away from the nearest dwellings, or ducting the discharge upward, is often more effective than adding height to a boundary barrier, and it costs a fraction as much.
Trains draw current in bursts, so the transformer is loaded intermittently and the cooling plant switches on and off with it. That produces a noise climate that is quiet, then loud, then quiet again, at intervals that can be short and irregular.
Cyclic variation is more noticeable than a steady level, even at the same equivalent level.
Fan start and stop adds a transient at each cycle, which is often what is reported rather than the steady hum.
Load dependent hum means a measurement taken at low load understates the night-time condition.
Regenerative braking can change load patterns, and with them the noise pattern, on routes where it is used.
More than at the boundary. A barrier placed a few metres from the transformer has a shorter path to its top edge than a boundary wall, so diffraction is less efficient and the insertion loss is higher for the same height.
The limit is access and fire separation: the barrier must not obstruct transformer removal, cable routing or the clearance the operator needs for maintenance and for arc protection. That is why compound barriers are usually low and close, rather than high and at the fence.
When the dominant residual source is the cooling plant, or when the barrier is required for the broadband plant and the hum is already controlled at the transformer. Building a boundary wall to solve an untreated hum is the most common way to spend money without reducing the complaint.
Sound power or sound pressure level at a defined distance, per IEC 60076-10, for the transformer itself.
Separate measurements with cooling plant running and stopped, so the two sources can be quantified.
Third octave spectra, because the tonal penalty in the assessment depends on the spectrum, not on the overall level.
Measurements at the nearest dwelling, not only at the boundary, since the two can differ in which source dominates.
A night-time measurement, because that is the condition that generates the complaint.
IEC 60076-10 — determination of sound levels for power transformers.
ISO 1996-1 and ISO 1996-2 — environmental noise assessment, including tonal adjustment.
ISO 9613-2 — outdoor sound propagation, for the broadband components.
EN 14388 and EN 1793-1 — barrier specification and absorption rating.
Related reading: industrial noise barrier systems, heat pump screening, and wind load and post spacing.
Only marginally. At 100 Hz the wavelength is about 3.4 m, so a barrier of practical height is acoustically small and sound diffracts over it. Hum is better addressed by specifying a quieter transformer, isolating it, or enclosing it.
Magnetostriction makes the core laminations change dimension twice per supply cycle, producing a tone at twice the supply frequency: 100 Hz on a 50 Hz system, with a harmonic series above it.
Yes. Fan and radiator noise is broadband and mid to high frequency, which a barrier screens effectively, provided the discharge is in the line of sight. Orienting the radiator away from dwellings is often cheaper still.
Buying a transformer with a guaranteed low sound level, since the reduction is designed into the core. Isolation and enclosure come next; boundary screening is the last and weakest step for hum.
Because background noise is lowest then, so the substation becomes prominent, and because traction load and cooling demand often peak at night. A daytime measurement can miss the condition that causes the complaint.
Contact Us
Imfornation
Substation and Transformer Noise Barriers: Controlling Low-Frequency HumGabion Mattress: Channel Lining and Scour ProtectionGabion Basket Supplier3D Curved Fence Panel ManufacturersHighway Noise Barrier Foundation: Piles, Footings and Soft GroundGenerator Noise Barrier: Tonal Noise and AirflowNoise Barrier Wind Load: Posts, Spacing and FoundationsAnti-Climb Fence Specification: 358 Mesh, Paladin Pales and 3D Panels4 Meter Noise Barrier PanelResidential Noise Barrier: Height, Planning and AppearanceMetal Noise Barrier ManufacturerShopping Centre Noise: Rooftop Plant and DeliveriesConstruction Hoarding Panels: Wind Load and Site BoundariesWind Farm Noise: What a Barrier Can and Cannot DoAirport Noise Barrier: Ground Noise, Run-Up and PlantStadium Noise Barrier: Crowd, PA and Plant CompoundsRoad Viaduct Noise Barrier: Deck Edge, Parapet and Load LimitsNoise Barrier Panel Specifications: The Six NumbersNoise Barrier Maintenance: Inspection and RepairRailway Yard and Marshalling Noise Barrier: Shunting, Braking and CurvesSolar Noise Barrier Cost: What Drives the Price and the PaybackTemporary Noise Barrier: Rent or Buy, and What Drives CostInfrastructure Noise ControlHotel Noise: Kitchen Extract, Chillers and DeliveriesRail Overbridge Noise Barrier: When the Bridge Is the Source111Perforated Metal Noise Barrier: Open Area and AbsorptionExpressway Widening: Upgrading an Existing Noise BarrierFreight Railway Noise Barrier: Low Speed, High MassBiomass and CHP Noise: Fans, Vents and Continuous DutyHighway Noise Barrier Cost: What Drives the Price per Square MetreTunnel Approach Noise Barrier: Open Cut, Portal and Cut-and-Cover29 STC Noise Barrier WholesaleAluminum Alloy Noise Barrier SupplierFence Cost Per Metre: What Actually Moves the Price of a Boundary FenceNoise Barrier Guide: Types, Height, Cost and SelectionMetro Viaduct Noise Barrier: Deck Radiated NoiseLaboratory Noise: Fume Hoods, Compressors and VibrationConstruction Site Fencing: Temporary Panels, Welded Mesh or HoardingRetrofitting Noise Barriers to an Existing Highway: Constraints and SequenceGabion Retaining Wall: Sizing, Drainage and Stone FillSchool Noise Barrier: Cutting Traffic Noise at the ClassroomConstruction Site Noise Barriers: Temporary Screens That Move With the WorksIndustrial Plant Noise Barrier: Boundary Wall and Equipment EnclosureRailway and HSR Noise Barriers: Design for Speed and Clearance