hotproduct

Tunnel Approach Noise Barrier: Open Cut, Portal and Cut-and-Cover

When a tunnel is built to remove traffic noise from a neighbourhood, the assumption is that the tunnel solves the problem. It usually does — along the bored section. The difficulty is at the ends, where the road emerges into an open approach cutting before it reaches daylight, and where the noise that has been accumulating inside the tunnel is released in one place.

An open approach is acoustically awkward because it is a canyon with a road in it. The retaining walls on both sides reflect sound back and forth, the portal headwall reflects it forward, and the result is a source that radiates from a fixed opening rather than from a line of traffic. Barrier design at a portal is therefore about geometry and absorption, not about adding height along a straight run.

The open approach is louder than the bore

Inside the tunnel, sound is absorbed by the lining and by the vehicles themselves, and it is contained. At the approach, the cross-section opens out, the reflections become less diffuse, and the sound emerges as a beam aimed along the axis of the cutting. For a receiver positioned on that axis, the approach can be several decibels louder than the same traffic on open road, because the tunnel has been acting as a horn.

This is why a noise model that treats the tunnel as a line source and the approach as ordinary road under-predicts the level at the houses beyond the portal. The portal is a source in its own right, and it has to be modelled as one.

Why the portal itself is the worst point

  • The headwall reflects. A flat portal facade facing the receiver reflects the emerging sound forward rather than letting it spread.

  • The opening concentrates. Sound leaving a bounded opening does not radiate hemispherically; it is directed, and the cut-off frequency depends on the opening size.

  • The approach walls guide. Parallel retaining walls keep the beam narrow, so the level falls off more slowly with distance along the axis than it would in the open.

  • The road gradient lifts the source. Approaches climb towards daylight, so the source at the portal is higher than the road beyond it.

Cut-and-cover: the roof is the problem

Where the approach is covered rather than open, the structure behaves as a large radiating surface. Traffic noise inside excites the roof slab, the slab radiates to the ground above, and the result is a broad, low-frequency hum spread over the whole covered length rather than concentrated at an opening. A barrier at the edge of the cut-and-cover does not help, because the source is the roof itself.

The measures that work are structural and belong to the tunnel design: mass in the roof slab, a resilient layer between the track or road surface and the structure, and absorption on the soffit to reduce the sound that excites the slab in the first place. Once the roof is built, the options narrow sharply, which is why the acoustic requirement has to be in the tunnel specification rather than added at the end.

Barrier geometry at the approach

Along an open approach, the barrier is normally placed on top of the retaining walls, which has the advantage of a raised base and the disadvantage of every structural question that wall-top mounting brings. The more useful move is at the end: splaying the barrier outwards as it approaches the portal, so that the beam is widened and the receivers beside the portal are screened.

LocationDominant mechanismMeasure that works
Portal openingDirected radiation, headwall reflectionSplayed wing walls, absorptive portal soffit
Open approach wallsCanyon reflection between parallel wallsAbsorption on at least one face
Cut-and-cover roofStructure-borne radiation from the slabMass, resilient isolation, soffit absorption
Ventilation plantTonal fan noise at a fixed pointSilencer and local enclosure

Reflections inside the approach

Parallel retaining walls in an approach cutting produce the same canyon effect as a narrow railway corridor. Sound reflects between them, the level inside rises, and the benefit of any barrier placed at the top falls short of the free-field calculation.

The remedy is absorption, and the practical constraint is that a retaining wall face is difficult to treat after the fact. Where the walls are cast in situ, an absorptive panel fixed to the wall face is feasible; where they are diaphragm walls with a fair-faced finish, the fixing has to be designed, and the panels must be rated for the splash and dirt of a road environment. Specifying absorption on one wall at construction stage is far cheaper than retrofitting both later.

Ventilation plant at the portal

A tunnel needs fans, and the plant building or the fan discharge is often at the portal, close to the receivers that the tunnel was meant to protect. Fan noise is tonal and continuous, which means it attracts a rating penalty and is noticed at night.

It is also the easiest item on the site to treat, because it is fixed and enclosed. A silencer on the discharge, an acoustic louvre on the intake, and an enclosure around the plant room will typically do more per unit cost than any additional barrier height. The mistake is to leave the plant out of the acoustic model and then discover it after the road opens.

The construction stage is an opportunity

An approach cutting begins as a diaphragm wall or a secant pile wall, and that wall is designed for earth pressure and water. Asking at design stage whether it can also carry a barrier is far cheaper than asking after it is built, because the answer then requires a separate foundation line in a space that no longer exists.

  • State the barrier height and wind load before the wall reinforcement is fixed.

  • Provide a continuous upstand or a cast-in base plate detail at the top of the wall.

  • Leave a drainage path that the barrier does not block.

  • Reserve space for a maintenance platform or a reachable panel height.

Design sequence for a tunnelled scheme

  • Model the portal as a source, not as the end of a line source.

  • Fix the barrier line at the approach from the retaining wall geometry, not from an ideal offset.

  • Decide absorption on the approach walls before they are cast.

  • Treat the ventilation plant as a separate, fixed source.

  • If the approach is covered, put the acoustic requirement into the roof specification.

  • Check the receivers beside the portal, not only those on the axis.

Related reading: road engineering noise barriers, tunnel portal noise, and retaining wall mounting.

Tunnel Approach Noise Barrier: Open Cut, Portal and Cut-and-Cover

Frequently asked questions

Is the tunnel quieter than open road at the portal?

Not necessarily. The bore contains and absorbs sound, but the open approach acts as a horn and the portal radiates a directed beam. For receivers on the axis beyond the portal, the level can be higher than the same traffic on open road.

Why does a cut-and-cover roof radiate noise?

Because traffic inside excites the slab and the slab radiates to the ground above. It is a structure-borne path, so a barrier at the edge of the structure does nothing; the fix is mass, isolation and soffit absorption, decided at design stage.

What is a splayed wing wall for?

To widen the emerging beam and screen the receivers beside the portal rather than only those on the axis. A parallel-wing portal concentrates the sound forward; splaying it spreads and attenuates it.

Can absorption be added to an existing approach cutting?

Yes, as panels fixed to the wall face, but the fixing has to be designed for the wall type and the panels rated for a road environment. Retrofitting both walls is expensive, which is why one absorptive face is often specified at construction.

How much does the ventilation plant matter?

Often more than expected, because it is tonal, continuous and running at night. It is also the cheapest source on the site to treat, since a silencer and an enclosure on fixed plant cost far less than extra barrier height.

Contact Us

Imfornation

3D-Welded Mesh fencing system358 Security Fence: Mesh, Wire and Anti-Climb SpecificationNoise Barrier Height: How the Height Is Actually SetInfrastructure Noise ControlChain Link Fence: Wire, Mesh and Coating SelectionNoise Control SolutionsLight Rail Noise Barrier: Street Running and CurvesGabion Retaining Wall: Sizing, Drainage and Stone FillRetaining Wall Noise Barrier: Wall Top Mounting and Load PathToll Plaza Noise: Canopy Reflection and AccelerationSolar Noise Barrier Cost: What Drives the Price and the PaybackData Centre Cooling Noise: Louvre Screens and AirflowExpressway Widening: Upgrading an Existing Noise BarrierHighway Interchange Noise Barrier: Multi Level LayoutAt-Grade Railway Noise Barrier: Level Crossings and Track AccessCooling Tower Noise Barrier: Layout, Airflow and Panel DesignMetal Noise Barrier Manufacturer4 Meter Noise Barrier PanelDouble Wire Fence: 868 and 656 Panels, Posts and FixingsGabion Mattress: Channel Lining and Scour ProtectionPlace of Worship Noise Barrier: Chimes, PA and PlantRoad Viaduct Noise Barrier: Deck Edge, Parapet and Load LimitsConstruction Hoarding Panels: Wind Load and Site BoundariesMetro Depot Noise Barrier: Enclosure for Depots and Over-Track Development3D Curved Fence Panel ManufacturersRail and Transit Noise Barrier: Lines, Stations, DepotsGenerator Noise Barrier: Tonal Noise and AirflowHotel Noise: Kitchen Extract, Chillers and Deliveries0.85 NRC Noise Barrier WholesaleCar Park Noise: Ventilation, Ramps and Rooftop PlantRailway and HSR Noise Barriers: Design for Speed and ClearanceRailway Station Noise: Platforms, Plant and Approaches29 STC Noise Barrier WholesaleStadium Noise Barrier: Crowd, PA and Plant CompoundsTemporary Fence: Panels, Ballast and Wind Load on SiteTunnel Portal Noise: Hoods, Barriers and Absorption111Shopping Centre Noise: Rooftop Plant and DeliveriesNoise barriers costCutting and Embankment Noise Barrier: Section GeometryGabion Baskets for saleSubstation and Transformer Noise Barriers: Controlling Low-Frequency HumHospital Noise Barrier: Ward Targets, Height and CleanabilityNoise Barrier Guide: Types, Height, Cost and SelectionMining and Quarry Noise Barriers: Dust, Plant and Layout